Individuals attend an interfaith service on October 29, 2018 at Adas Israel Congregation in Washington, D.C.
Alex Wong/Getty Photos/Getty Photos North America
conceal caption
toggle caption
Alex Wong/Getty Photos/Getty Photos North America
Greater than 1,000 rabbis and different Jewish leaders from across the globe, together with in Israel and the U.S., have signed a public letter urging Israel to permit in depth humanitarian assist into Gaza.
The letter denounces Israel’s “mass killings of civilians” and “the use and risk of hunger as a weapon of struggle.” The Jewish leaders say Israel’s actions injury not simply the nation’s status, however Judaism itself.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has denied experiences of hunger in Gaza. Nonetheless, the letter calls upon Netanyahu and the Israeli authorities “to respect all harmless life.”
Rabbis from a number of denominations within the U.S., Canada, Israel and throughout Europe have signed the letter, which focuses on hunger and the humanitarian disaster in Gaza, however doesn’t denounce the struggle. The signatories clearly state that they help Israel’s battle in opposition to Hamas.
Former Rabbi Charles Feinberg led Adas Israel Congregation, the biggest Conservative synagogue in Washington, D.C. for over eight years. Israel is a “supply of nice satisfaction” for a lot of Jewish folks, Feinberg stated, including nevertheless that he’s “disturbed by the conduct of the struggle.” He known as the shortage of meals assist in Gaza “a horrible assault on Jewish ethics.”
“I believe it’s a actual check of our religion. And that is why that is such an essential second,” he informed Morning Version. “We, Jews, say day by day a line: ‘Hear, O Israel, the Lord, our God, the Lord is one.’ And so, will we nonetheless consider that God is one? That God is one implies that God cares about each human being, not simply Jewish folks.”
Many American Jews nonetheless help the struggle and stand firmly behind Israel, however rising numbers, significantly youthful Jews, have grown pissed off with the size and devastation of the battle that started almost two years in the past. Some are stepping away from mainstream Jewish establishments altogether, in keeping with Yonat Shimron, a senior editor at Faith Information Service.
In a dialog with NPR’s Steve Inskeep, Feinberg explains why he signed the letter and what Jewish leaders need from Israel.
The next dialog has been edited for size and readability.
Interview Highlights
Steve Inskeep: Why signal this letter now?
Charles Feinberg: Oh, I believe I actually am significantly disturbed by the conduct of the struggle, and the shortage of meals assist inside Gaza simply appears to be a horrible assault on Jewish ethics, truly.
Inskeep: Is it clear from you observing this that you just consider it’s inside Israel’s energy to do extra and to permit greater than they’re at present doing?
Feinberg: Sure, I consider that that is a part of the accountability of the army operation, is to supply for the civilian inhabitants.
In Gaza, folks line up for meals distribution.
AFP through Getty Photos
conceal caption
toggle caption
AFP through Getty Photos
In Gaza, folks line up for meals distribution.
AFP through Getty Photos
Inskeep: Now, in studying the letter that you just signed, it begins by saying this, “The Jewish Individuals face a grave ethical disaster, threatening the very foundation of Judaism as the moral voice that it has been.” What about this disaster appears to you to implicate your total religion?
Feinberg: Nicely, I believe it’s a actual check of our religion. And that is why that is such an essential second. We, Jews, say day by day a line, ‘Hear, O Israel, the Lord, our God, the Lord is one.’ And so, will we nonetheless consider that God is one? That God is one implies that God cares about each human being, not simply Jewish folks. And so the truth that assist shouldn’t be being given in an environment friendly means, in a means that folks can obtain [and] in a means that is not too expensive, is de facto an essential Jewish worth as a result of we consider God is one.
Inskeep: What have you considered once you’ve heard the Israeli authorities’s response? The prime minister says there is not any hunger. Different Israeli officers will blame Hamas.
Feinberg: Sure. Nicely, I believe that is a part of the issue, there was no actual resolution about what ought to be the top of this struggle. And I believe that is additionally very regarding, that there is not any plan about how you can finish the struggle.
Inskeep: In fact, you want two events to make peace. Hamas is a part of this, however Israel has declined to sketch out what it desires the top of the struggle to be.
Feinberg: And it isn’t taken any steps to arrange civilian society inside Gaza.
Inskeep: Are you able to describe how, if in any respect, this has more and more divided American Jews? If we take into consideration folks in your prolonged household or in your neighborhood or within the congregation that you just led for thus lengthy.
Feinberg: Sure, there may be plenty of pressure about this as a result of Jewish individuals are pulled in several instructions. The state of Israel has all the time been a supply of nice satisfaction to Jewish folks, and now we have supported it. And it has been a part of a dream that we’d have our personal state and that we’d have our personal energy to guard ourselves. However a part of having energy is to be accountable with it. And there is plenty of debate throughout the Jewish group of what which means.
Inskeep: And the Jewish group is legendary for debate. However I’m wondering if that is attending to be a kind of discussions the place you’ll be able to’t even stand to have the talk. You must fall silent nearly amongst folks you like.
Feinberg: That’s true. And I believe over the previous couple of years, it has been troublesome to publicly debate a few of these points as a result of feelings are so excessive. And rabbis have been reluctant to handle a few of these points as a result of they’re so fearful that it could cut up their group.
Inskeep: We heard within the report earlier that the letter requires humanitarian assist for Gaza, however stays in help of the struggle, the struggle in opposition to Hamas. Are you able to clarify how each of these issues may be true on the identical time?
Feinberg: Nicely, Hamas is a small faction throughout the Palestinian folks. And they also have to be eradicated and overcome. What I consider, strongly, is that we have to help these Palestinians who do wish to make peace with Israel. And there are lots of Israeli Jews and Palestinians who’re working collectively to consider a solution to resolve the battle. And we have to put our effort in supporting these teams.
The audio story was produced by Nia Dumas and edited by Mohamad ElBardicy. The digital story was edited by Olivia Hampton.
