NPR’s Scott Simon speaks with Richard Nephew, a senior analysis scholar at Columbia College, concerning the prospect of a brand new nuclear deal between Iran and the U.S.
SCOTT SIMON, HOST:
Assessments proceed to vary on the harm completed to Iran’s nuclear amenities after U.S. and Israeli bombings. The newest point out that Iran’s nuclear program may very well be set again a 12 months or two. Now, Iranian officers keep they’ve the correct to proceed what they insist is a civilian nuclear program. However any enrichment is at the moment a purple line for the Trump administration, and talks are scheduled subsequent week between Iran and the U.S. and Oslo.
Richard Nephew is senior analysis scholar at Columbia College. He served as deputy particular envoy for Iran throughout the Biden administration and on the Nationwide Safety Council and within the State Division throughout the Obama administration. Mr. Nephew, thanks a lot for being with us.
RICHARD NEPHEW: Thanks for having me.
SIMON: In a chunk for International Affairs, you wrote that if Iran managed to cover and bury its stockpile of extremely enriched uranium, that might give them what you referred to as breakout choices. What are these?
NEPHEW: So principally, after we speak about breakout, we’re speaking about Iran’s skill to supply sufficient materials for its first nuclear weapon, after which to have the ability to take that materials and to place it into bomb elements. And if Iran has been capable of conceal after which discover once more all the extremely enriched uranium that that they had produced beforehand, they might have a reasonably fast skill to maneuver in direction of nuclear weapons.
SIMON: And I’ve to ask – this week, Iran’s president signed a brand new regulation that suspends cooperation with U.N. nuclear inspectors. That was a key side of Iran turning into a signatory to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty. How do you learn this transfer?
NEPHEW: Nicely, I feel at two ranges. First, you understand, I feel the Iranians are involved that the worldwide inspectors have given info – you understand, even simply publicly – which may have enabled Israeli and U.S. army strikes. However second, you understand, if the Iranians do have an intent to try to race in direction of a bomb, ensuring that worldwide inspectors aren’t there wanting is likely one of the first steps that you’d take.
SIMON: You had been on the staff that negotiated the nuclear deal a decade in the past. Over the previous few weeks, we have seen a lot of Iran’s protection system broken. May this create an incentive for a deal or simply the other?
NEPHEW: I imply, it may create an incentive for a deal. However I feel the more likely consequence – particularly contemplating how a lot Iran’s nuclear program could have been hidden – is that the Iranians as an alternative will say, OK, you understand, we, you understand, do not significantly like the thought of being attacked once more. You realize, what’s one of the simplest ways that we will stave that off? And that is if we reveal that we have got nuclear weapons functionality – one thing that they are able to do comparatively shortly and cheaply, particularly when thought-about with how a lot effort can be required to rebuild their missile program, the air protection programs. You realize, these types of issues.
SIMON: Nicely, and that raises possibly an general query. Has this current warfare and the alternate of missiles simply persuaded Iran’s management that what they should keep in energy is a nuclear weapon?
NEPHEW: Yeah, that is my large fear. You realize, look – once you determine to enter army drive to handle a nuclear downside, frankly, you higher not miss. And you have to just remember to’re capable of cope with all of the features of that nuclear program as a result of in any other case, what you’ve got signaled is, you understand, you are defenseless. You realize, we now have the power to overfly you at will. You realize, we now have the power to assault your amenities and your cities at will. And I feel any state would take a look at that scenario and say, effectively, we’d like one thing that is going to scare all people not to try this. And it is particularly the case when you’re the Iranians, and when you’ve already type of come into the worldwide system with a way that everybody’s out to get you. I actually suppose the Iranian state’s view at this level has obtained to be about, you understand, making an attempt to make sure regime survival, and that factors within the path of nuclear weapons.
SIMON: On the identical time, let me ask you concerning the impact of sanctions. President Trump, in fact, left that nuclear settlement in his first time period and imposed harsh sanctions. Do they supply an incentive for Iran to pursue negotiations and never have a nuclear growth program?
NEPHEW: They definitely may, or at the least sanctions aid, proper? So at this level, we have in all probability imposed sanctions on every little thing that we will. There’s nonetheless Iran’s skill to export a small quantity of oil to China. That is, at this level, type of conserving the Iranian financial system afloat. However proper now the most effective incentive that we have got to the Iranians to not pursue nuclear weapons is to say, OK, we’re ready to alleviate an entire bunch of sanctions towards you – permit you to do much more enterprise internationally, permit cash to move in, permit reconstruction – and in alternate, have circumstances on the nuclear program, presumably the missile program and different issues. Essentially, that was what the nuclear deal again in 2015 did.
Now we now have a bit of little bit of a bonus by the nuclear program having been badly broken. On the identical time, the Iranians now have a deep mistrust of america. We have already withdrawn from one deal. Now we have joined in a army assault. There isn’t any clear indication we will maintain the Israelis from attacking once more in the event that they wish to. So, you understand, all these issues add as much as being a reasonably powerful promote on the diplomatic facet.
SIMON: Nicely, and that raises this remaining query. Given your expertise negotiating with Iranian officers, what sort of deal do you suppose is perhaps potential? Or are the talks only for present?
NEPHEW: I do not suppose they’re for present, and I feel the Iranians would do a deal. However I do suppose that getting them to just accept no uranium enrichment within the nation ceaselessly and ever might be past what we’re capable of obtain. You realize, I feel the Iranians will insist on having at the least some notional functionality. Whether or not or not they really execute that could be a complete separate query.
SIMON: A notional functionality which means the power to develop nuclear energy for civilian makes use of.
NEPHEW: Precisely, and that is perhaps restricted. That is perhaps, you understand, circumscribed. It is perhaps time-limited – you understand, you can begin this program in 15 years when you’ve gotten your first reactors being constructed that may, you understand, truly use enriched uranium. I can think about that type of deal. However in any other case, it is going to be fairly troublesome, I feel, to get the Iranians to just accept one thing now.
SIMON: Richard Nephew at Columbia. Thanks a lot for talking with us.
NEPHEW: Thanks.
(SOUNDBITE OF THE RUGGED NUGGETS’ “RUGGED WALK”)
Copyright © 2025 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional info.
Accuracy and availability of NPR transcripts could fluctuate. Transcript textual content could also be revised to appropriate errors or match updates to audio. Audio on npr.org could also be edited after its unique broadcast or publication. The authoritative report of NPR’s programming is the audio report.
