Suno and Udio have been slapped with one other spherical of copyright litigation, this time by nation musician Tony Justice, who filed class-action lawsuits in opposition to each controversial AI music turbines.
The complaints allege Suno and Udio used Justice’s recordings and works from “1000’s of sophistication members” with out authorization to coach their AI fashions.
Justice and his label, fifth Wheel Data, filed the lawsuit in opposition to Suno (which you’ll be able to learn right here) in Massachusetts, and the case in opposition to Udio (learn right here) in New York.
The 23- and 24-page lawsuits argue that whereas main labels pursue their very own infringement circumstances, unbiased artists “whose rights have been trampled essentially the most” stay excluded from “the desk, unrepresented, and with no significant treatment.”
In June final 12 months, the main music corporations sued the AI startups within the US for allegedly coaching their programs utilizing the businesses’ recordings with out permission – an accusation they just about admitted to in courtroom filings final August.
Most just lately, Justice’s grievance states: “Slightly than merely license these copyrighted songs like each different tech-based enterprise does, Suno/Udio elected to easily steal the songs and generate AI-soundalike music at nearly no price to Suno/Udio.”
“Slightly than merely license these copyrighted songs like each different tech-based enterprise does, Suno/Udio elected to easily steal the songs.”
Tony Justice’s lawsuit
Justice’s authorized workforce contains Krystle Delgado, an lawyer who additionally performs as a musician.
As with the lawsuits filed by the three majors, the brand new circumstances problem the AI corporations’ argument that coaching fashions on copyrighted materials constitutes honest use beneath copyright regulation.
Justice’s lawsuits contest this place, citing current steerage from the US Copyright Workplace. It cited the workplace’s Might 2025 report: Copyright and Synthetic Intelligence, Half 3: Generative AI Coaching, which in line with the lawsuit, “emphasised that the honest use doctrine doesn’t excuse unauthorized coaching on expressive works (e.g., music) notably when these works are used to generate substitutional outputs that will change the originals within the related market.”
“The method wherein Suno’s/Udio’s AI mannequin trains, by way of the copy and copying of present copyrighted songs, constitutes prima facie copyright infringement.”
Tony Justice’s lawsuit
“Suno/Udio coaching its AI mannequin on the copyrighted songs of unbiased artists, Plaintiffs and Class Members, with out authorization, to then create competing music in the very same market, is unlikely honest use, and due to this fact, is prima facie copyright infringement.”
The Copyright Workplace report referenced within the lawsuits warns that AI coaching includes a number of copy acts that might represent infringement.
“Which means, the method wherein Suno’s/Udio’s AI mannequin trains, by way of the copy and copying of present copyrighted songs, constitutes prima facie copyright infringement,” in line with the lawsuit.
Justice’s web site describes him as “one in every of nation music’s most talked about unbiased artists” and a “full-time truck driver.” His music, Final of the Cowboys, has collected over 8 million streams on Spotify, the place he has over 54,700 month-to-month listeners. On YouTube, Justice has attracted over 28,000 subscribers.
His lawsuits in opposition to Suno and Udio search to ascertain a category motion overlaying all unbiased artists, songwriters, and producers whose works appeared on streaming providers since January 1, 2021.
Justice seeks everlasting injunctions stopping additional unauthorized use of copyrighted works, plus damages as much as $150,000 per infringed work.
Suno can be going through a copyright infringement lawsuit in Germany, filed in January 2025 by GEMA, the German assortment society and licensing physique.
The most recent lawsuits in opposition to the 2 AI corporations arrive about two weeks after Bloomberg reported, citing individuals conversant in the discussions, that the three majors are in search of license charges from the platforms plus “a small quantity” of fairness in each companies.
Music Enterprise Worldwide
