Keep knowledgeable with free updates
Merely signal as much as the EU power myFT Digest — delivered on to your inbox.
Spain’s grid operator has accused some massive energy crops of not doing their job to assist regulate the nation’s electrical energy system within the moments earlier than final month’s catastrophic blackout throughout the Iberian peninsula.
Beatriz Corredor, chair of grid operator Pink Eléctrica’s mum or dad firm, mentioned energy crops fell brief in controlling the voltage of the electrical energy system.
Nevertheless, the heads of Spain’s largest plant house owners linked the blackout to a scarcity of grid funding and inadequate efforts to spice up electrical energy demand.
The general public blame recreation over the outage is intensifying as greater than three weeks after 60mn individuals have been left with out energy, Spanish authorities investigators insisted they wanted extra time to determine the basis trigger.
The revelations on Thursday from Corredor, chair of Redeia, open up a brand new entrance after the highlight fell initially on Spain’s excessive dependence on wind and photo voltaic power as a doable reason behind the blackout.
Corredor didn’t say massive energy crops have been the basis trigger, however she mentioned the functioning of sure gasoline, nuclear or hydroelectric amenities in south-west Spain was “under [the levels] required by present voltage management rules”.
Their position is doubtlessly important as a result of consultants have recognized the proximate reason behind the blackout as a surge in voltage on the grid, along with a drop within the frequency at which {the electrical} present alternates, which triggered the disconnection of a number of technology crops.
Corredor insisted that moments earlier than the failure on April 28, the a part of the system managed by Pink Eléctrica, together with grid substations, was working throughout the voltage ranges established by regulatory norms.
“So we now have to think about what was occurring with voltage in the remainder of the system,” she mentioned. “As a result of [Red Eléctrica] are the mind, the backbone. However this technique clearly has arms, legs, and it has a coronary heart, which is the crops that generate electrical energy.”
Voltage surges on the grid trigger energy crops to disconnect mechanically for security causes to guard tools from harm.
Corredor mentioned voltage variations “had so much to do with” the position of energy crops in regulating ranges by “absorbing” what is named reactive energy, a portion of electrical energy that oscillates between turbines and ultimate shoppers. Her competition was that absorption ranges shortly earlier than the blackout have been too low.
Spain’s three largest energy plant house owners are Endesa, Iberdrola and Naturgy.
One energy sector official pushed again in opposition to the claims, saying “the ability crops supplied the perfect providers they may regardless of the irregular behaviour of the transmission grid”, which is run by Pink Eléctrica.
The official mentioned Pink Eléctrica “might have activated extra energy crops to manage voltage and take in reactive energy, each the day earlier than and in the course of the morning [of April 28]”.
José Bogas, Endesa’s chief govt, mentioned on Thursday an important lesson of the ability failure was that Spain had did not replace its grid for an period of heavy dependence on wind and photo voltaic — which have been contributing about 70 per cent of its electrical energy simply earlier than the blackout.
Talking earlier than Corredor at an occasion organised by the newspaper Expansión, Bogas famous that particular person renewable installations have been — in contrast with conventional fossil gas and nuclear energy crops — smaller, extra dispersed and farther from large centres of consumption.
However he mentioned: “I believe we now have continued to function the system as we did once we [depended more on] the big [traditional] energy crops.”
Mario Ruiz-Tagle, chief govt of Iberdrola’s Spain enterprise, mentioned one underlying drawback was that the nation had not carried out sufficient to foster demand for all of the electrical energy it might produce.
“The issue isn’t the quantity of renewable power we now have. The issue is ensuring we use these renewables in order that trade may be electrified, in order that electrical automobiles may be extra widespread, in order that warmth pumps may be extra widespread.”
