Restrictive practices in psychological well being settings—equivalent to bodily restraint and seclusion—are supposed to be a final resort, used solely when sufferers pose a threat to themselves or others.
In 2021 and 2022 alone, NHS England reported that 6,600 psychological well being sufferers had been subjected to bodily restraint, and 4,500 to seclusion. Figures equivalent to these have led quite a few specialists and policymakers to conclude that restrictive practices are overused in psychological well being inpatient settings.
The results could be devastating. Restrictive practices are related to trauma, worsening psychological well being, and even demise. For many years, clinicians, researchers and policymakers have known as for his or her discount. Progress, nevertheless, stays painfully gradual.
For the previous 5 years, I’ve been researching the usage of restrictive practices in psychological well being providers and exploring the best way to scale back them. My new analysis demonstrates the significance of utilizing compassion to help workers to advertise the dignity and well-being of sufferers as a precedence.
Restrictive practices have an extended historical past that predates the event of asylums and psychiatry as a medical self-discipline. The usage of laws to detain individuals on the idea of their psychological well being in England, for instance, dates again to not less than the 14th century. Early examples of restrictive practices included sufferers being certain and overwhelmed with rods to be able to “restore sanity.”
Throughout the first three many years of the nineteenth century, mechanical restraints equivalent to straitjackets, chains and restraint chairs and confining sufferers in locked rooms had been extensively accepted strategies of controlling violent individuals in British asylums. However within the 1830s, some clinicians acknowledged the ethical and moral issues with utilizing such practices, and a marketing campaign started to abolish them.
The UN has lengthy acknowledged restrictive practices in psychological well being care as a human rights problem. In 2008, the UN’s particular rapporteur on torture said that strategies equivalent to solitary confinement violate articles 14 and 15 of the Conference on the Rights of Individuals with Disabilities, which defend in opposition to arbitrary detention and merciless, inhuman or degrading therapy.
This stance was reaffirmed in 2021 when the UN declared that restrictive practices breach the basic rights of sufferers. This underscores the pressing want for reform in psychological well being care techniques worldwide.
Dangerous impact
Analysis exhibits that restrictive practices might not solely hurt sufferers however contradict the objectives of psychological well being care. Many psychological well being issues stem from traumatic experiences that go away individuals feeling powerless, unsafe and distressed. Utilizing strategies that reinforce these emotions can worsen the very points providers purpose to handle.
In excessive incidents, individuals have died on account of restrictive practices use.
In my analysis, I’ve developed a theoretical mannequin figuring out core components that perpetuate the usage of restrictive practices in psychological well being providers. These embody the emotional challenges confronted by workers working in high-stress environments, and the way these challenges affect their decision-making.
Psychological well being wards could be extremely demanding environments, with frequent incidents of aggression. In such settings, workers can usually really feel anxious and hyper-vigilant, which may make it tougher for them to reply to sufferers with compassion.
Analysis exhibits that threat-based feelings like worry and anger are linked to a larger chance of utilizing restrictive measures. So, this cycle perpetuates the usage of these dangerous practices.
Compassion might maintain the important thing
Utilizing restrictive practices to regulate or take away people who find themselves perceived as a menace can present workers with a way of fast security, which can inadvertently reinforce their use. To handle this, I needed to discover whether or not supporting workers to handle their feelings extra successfully may scale back their reliance on restrictive practices, and foster a extra compassionate strategy to care.
As a part of my analysis, I launched compassion-focused help teams for employees in a number of forensic psychological well being wards, advocating for a extra empathetic and patient-centered strategy. These teams tried to equip members with abilities to higher handle difficult emotional experiences whereas fostering larger compassion for each themselves and the individuals of their care.
The purpose was to assist workers domesticate an interior sense of security, lowering their reliance on restrictive practices as a method of managing their very own emotions of menace. This intervention was encouraging, resulting in reductions in the usage of restrictive practices in some circumstances—demonstrating the potential of utilizing compassionate take care of these functions.
My research was the primary of its sort—however these preliminary outcomes spotlight the necessity for additional analysis into how the emotional administration of workers influences care choices. The journey towards change is gradual, however it’s potential. Compassion might maintain the important thing to addressing a deeply entrenched problem that has formed the therapy of psychological well being sufferers for hundreds of years.
Extra data:
Daniel Lawrence et al, Utilizing a brief‐time period threat evaluation and compassion centered workers help teams to scale back restrictive intervention use in a safe psychological well being service, British Journal of Medical Psychology (2025). DOI: 10.1111/bjc.70004
This text is republished from The Dialog beneath a Inventive Commons license. Learn the authentic article.
Quotation:
Bodily proscribing psychological well being sufferers can usually hurt them. New research suggests compassion may change that (2025, July 23)
retrieved 23 July 2025
from https://medicalxpress.com/information/2025-07-physically-restricting-mental-health-patients.html
This doc is topic to copyright. Other than any honest dealing for the aim of personal research or analysis, no
half could also be reproduced with out the written permission. The content material is offered for data functions solely.
