Dr. John Lott has a brand new op-ed on the Washington Occasions.
.
The declare that unlawful aliens commit crimes at decrease charges than native-born Individuals might look convincing, nevertheless it doesn’t maintain up underneath scrutiny. One of many loudest advocates of this narrative has been the libertarian CATO Institute. Its experiences, extensively coated by the media, proceed to assist form public opinion—together with its newest launch titled “Unlawful Immigrant Incarceration Charges, 2010–2023.” They declare that unlawful aliens commit crime at half the speed of native-born Individuals and that authorized immigrants commit crime at only a quarter of the speed.
.
However similar to their earlier related efforts, this report falls in need of credible evaluation.
.
CATO’s technique appears to be working. A McLaughlin & Associates survey commissioned by the Crime Prevention Analysis Heart on April 29, 2025—simply days after CATO launched its newest report—reveals that 41.6% of voters now consider unlawful immigrants commit fewer crimes than U.S. residents. Solely 33.3% assume the alternative.
.
To again its claims, CATO as soon as once more leans closely on information from the American Neighborhood Survey (ACS). However the institute by no means adequately explains how flawed this dataset is for measuring crime charges when utilized to unlawful immigration. The ACS surveys about 3.5 million U.S. addresses every year and asks individuals to reply on-line or by mail. CATO particularly makes use of ACS information on jail populations to estimate what number of inmates are unlawful immigrants.
.
This technique introduces critical bias. The ACS doubtless undercounts felony exercise amongst unlawful immigrants, resulting in skewed outcomes that understate the actual scale of the problem.
.
For instance, immigration authorities usually deport undocumented immigrants straight from jail earlier than they end their sentences. In early 2025, for instance, about half of the people ICE highlighted in enforcement actions have been already incarcerated on the time of their arrest. This follow skews crime information by underrepresenting unlawful aliens in jail inhabitants statistics.
.
ICE’s Enforcement and Removing Operations (ERO) data additionally present that native jails regularly switch noncitizens arrested for crimes like DUI, drug possession, or assault to ICE custody—earlier than the offenders serve any time in jail.
.
Authorities may additionally deport unlawful aliens after arrest even earlier than conviction or sentencing. These removals usually consequence from insurance policies that prioritize immigration enforcement over felony prosecution. As a result of coming into or remaining within the U.S. with out authorization already qualifies a person for deportation, a conviction isn’t required to take away them.
.
In the meantime, the Cato Institute assumes that anybody receiving federal advantages—reminiscent of welfare, well being care, or Social Safety—is within the U.S. legally and that program fraud doesn’t happen. But, a 2024 audit by the U.S. Well being and Human Companies Inspector Basic underneath the Biden administration discovered California improperly claimed $52.7 million in federal Medicaid reimbursements for unlawful aliens. Unlawful immigrants have fraudulently accessed a variety of packages, together with Social Safety and public housing.
.
The American Neighborhood Survey (ACS) provides one other layer of bias. As a result of the survey is voluntary, undocumented immigrants—whether or not in jail or not—have a robust incentive to hide their immigration standing. Regardless of assurances that their solutions received’t be shared with legislation enforcement, inmates know that disclosing their undocumented standing might improve their chance of deportation. This results in additional underreporting within the ACS information.
.
The information presents a clearer hyperlink between unlawful immigration and crime. In truth, simply final yr, even the Biden administration admitted that 9% of the so-called “non-detained” unlawful immigrants—662,566 out of seven.4 million launched into the U.S.—had felony data. What makes this much more alarming is that these people have been largely those that voluntarily turned themselves in on the border—those supposedly least prone to pose a menace. These numbers don’t even embrace the 2 million identified “gotaways” who crossed the border with out being apprehended in the course of the Biden administration, nor the unknown hundreds of thousands who evaded detection solely. And that 9% determine assumes the administration didn’t undercount felony data—which is questionable, particularly since international locations like Venezuela usually refuse to share background data on their residents.
.
It’s arduous to disregard the unprecedented proportion improve in violent crime in the course of the Biden administration as unlawful immigrants flooded into the nation. And that the U.S. homicide price is on observe for the bottom homicide price on report as deportations rise.
.
A previous Maricopa County Legal professional’s Workplace examine revealed that unlawful immigrants dedicated 21.8% of felonies sentenced in Maricopa County Superior Court docket, over twice their proportion of Arizona’s inhabitants. Mexican nationals alone accounted for 13% of inmates within the state jail system. Different analysis taking a look at Arizona state jail information reveals Unlawful immigrants are at the very least 142% extra prone to be convicted of against the law than different Arizonans.
.
CATO has lengthy pushed an open-borders agenda—an method that even free-market economist Milton Friedman warned would fail in a rustic with a big welfare system. CATO’s continued selective use of flawed information solely reinforces how unreliable its claims are.
.
