-
Ben Solak
The 2025 NFL draft is within the books, which implies everybody’s favourite little bit of content material — Approach-Too-Early 2026 mock drafts — is flying off the cabinets. I’ve one other piece of Approach-Too-Early content material for you: 2025 Rookie of the 12 months rankings for each side of the ball.
“How are you going to rank the Rookie of the 12 months candidates earlier than a single snap has been performed?” the timid and unimaginative cry in concern.
Simply! Offensive and Defensive Rookie of the 12 months voters observe pretty predictable patterns which might be closely influenced by draft capital spent. Manufacturing is likewise affected by touchdown spots, as just some rookies are instantly given excessive snap counts. Most are as a substitute dropped into depth charts and need to earn their method to taking part in time.
Let’s stroll via my logic for every set of Rookie of the 12 months rankings — beginning with the earliest-drafted gamers, then including candidates and rising the size of the lists as I am going. I am going to begin on offense, the place I finally ranked 18 gamers.
Learn extra on 2025 rookies:
Miller’s favourite picks | Kiper’s grades
Offensive Rookie of the 12 months
The present favourite for Offensive Rookie of the 12 months is Raiders operating again Ashton Jeanty (+275 at ESPN BET). In some methods, that is unsurprising. Chosen with the sixth decide, Jeanty is the earliest-drafted operating again since Saquon Barkley went second in 2018, and Barkley was the final operating again to win the award. Jeanty was additionally thought of among the finest prospects within the class, definitely higher than Cam Ward, the Titans quarterback who went first as a product of the premium positioned on his place. Although the Raiders’ offensive line would not essentially lend itself to inspiring run-game visions, the mix of offensive coordinator Chip Kelly and a backfield bereft of competitors spells a high-volume future for Jeanty.
However it’s value noting that Ward is the second favourite, and up to date historical past leans on the quarterbacks. In 2004, Ben Roethlisberger turned solely the second QB to win the award. However since Roethlisberger, 9 of the 20 Offensive Rookies of the 12 months have been quarterbacks. So many extra signal-callers play as rookies today than in a long time previous, and accordingly, there are extra candidates for the award. In an identical vein, it is a lot simpler for quarterbacks to supply larger numbers in trendy offenses, which are inclined to skew pass-heavy.
The previous two OROY winners are instructive. In 2023, quarterback C.J. Stroud gained the award over Puka Nacua even though the large receiver set rookie data in each receptions (105) and yardage (1,486). In 2024, Jayden Daniels gained the award over tight finish Brock Bowers, who broke Nacua’s rookie receptions report with 112 and Mike Ditka’s mark for many receiving yards by a rookie tight finish with 1,194. Ditka’s report had stood since 1961.
Stroud and Daniels have been deserving, after all. However their clear victories — Stroud acquired 48 of a potential 50 first-place votes, whereas Daniels acquired 49 — emphasize the inescapable bias towards quarterbacks that permeates NFL awards voting. When confronted with a superb QB and a very good non-QB, voters gravitate towards the previous.
As such, my favourite for Offensive Rookie of the 12 months is Ward, the one passer with an apparent path to beginning the overwhelming majority of the 2025 season. He lands in a strong atmosphere in Tennessee. The offensive line has been improved throughout all 5 positions over the previous two seasons, and whereas the receiving room is not superb, no one rated Washington’s 2024 group or Houston’s 2023 group as spectacular. The subsequent-drafted quarterbacks (Jaxson Dart with the Giants and Tyler Shough with the Saints) are behind veterans, although the unsure well being of Derek Carr (shoulder) bumps Shough above Dart for me.
So here is our place to begin constructing the OROY record:
1. Cam Ward, Titans
2. Ashton Jeanty, Raiders
3. Tyler Shough, Saints
4. Jaxson Dart, Giants
0:45
Will Tyler Shough be able to play immediately for Saints?
Jason McCourty analyzes the strengths of Saints quarterback Tyler Shough and if he’ll be able to play immediately with Derek Carr nursing a shoulder harm.
Now, what about large receiver? Solely three receivers gained the award between 2000 and 2020 (Anquan Boldin in 2003, Percy Harvin in 2009 and Odell Beckham Jr. in 2014). Harvin’s 2009 win is surprising by 2025 requirements: He caught 60 balls for 790 yards, rushed for an additional 135 yards and scored eight complete touchdowns — six receiving, two returning. It was a very powerful yr for rookies on offense. Early-drafted QBs Matthew Stafford and Mark Sanchez had extra interceptions than touchdowns, and early-drafted receivers Michael Crabtree and Darrius Heyward-Bey missed time. Knowshon Moreno, the primary operating again off the board, tied for third within the voting with Jeremy Maclin and Mike Wallace. Ravens proper sort out Michael Oher — sure, an offensive lineman! — was second.
As a basic rule, receivers want unsuccessful quarterback courses to win the award. In 2021, 5 quarterbacks went within the first 15 picks. However the best was the fifth one taken. Mac Jones threw for 3,801 yards, 22 touchdowns and 13 interceptions, and the Patriots earned a playoff berth. However that wasn’t sufficient to beat out Bengals WR Ja’Marr Chase, who set the rookie receiving yardage report (1,455) that Nucua would break just a few seasons later.
In 2022, the one quarterback to go within the first two rounds was Kenny Pickett (twentieth general), and he had about half as many passing touchdowns (7) in 12 begins as Brock Purdy (who went 262nd general) did in 5 (13). Had Purdy performed your complete season, he might need snuck the award away from Jets WR Garrett Wilson. However that is the factor about rookie quarterbacks — if they do not earn the beginning in Week 1, it is laborious for them to make up floor on the operating backs and receivers who get at the least some motion within the early video games. Wilson’s hottest competitors in 2022 was Seahawks operating again Kenneth Walker III, who acquired extra first-place votes however misplaced on the AP’s ranked-choice voting system.
It is affordable to count on this 2025 quarterback class to underwhelm in manufacturing, which opens up the sector. The highest large receiver in rivalry is inarguably Panthers first-rounder Tetairoa McMillan, who went 11 picks earlier than Emeka Egbuka (Buccaneers) and 15 earlier than Matthew Golden (Packers). Egbuka and Golden enter receiver rooms thick with established expertise and have difficult paths to dominant quantity. The Panthers, in the meantime, would love nothing greater than to funnel targets to McMillan as a substitute of an getting older Adam Thielen.
In Bryce Younger‘s resurgent finish to the 2024 season, the Panthers turned extraordinarily reliant on downfield targets — Younger was sixth in air yards per try from Week 8 onward. McMillan will probably be his finest ball-winner on contested throws downfield and a robust crimson zone goal. The potential for a 1,000-yard or 10-touchdown rookie season is there.
The elephant within the room is Jaguars WR/CB Travis Hunter, who can be a superb candidate for this award if he have been destined to play near 100% of the offensive snaps. However which may not be the case. The Jaguars’ plan for his or her two-way star is reportedly “fluid,” and as such, it is laborious to belief that Hunter may have a aggressive snap depend or goal share relative to previous winners at large receiver. I am going to slot him in on the Egbuka/Golden tier. (This is not the one record Hunter will seem on right here however — spoiler alert — I’ve snap depend issues on the opposite aspect of the ball as properly.)
1. Cam Ward, Titans
2. Ashton Jeanty, Raiders
3. Tetairoa McMillan, Panthers
4. Tyler Shough, Saints
5. Travis Hunter, Jaguars
6. Matthew Golden, Packers
7. Emeka Egbuka, Buccaneers
8. Jaxson Dart, Giants
Lastly, we return to the place the place we started: operating again. Apart from Jeanty, the one different again taken within the first spherical was Omarion Hampton, who joins the Chargers. Hampton’s alternative is unimaginable. With each J.Okay. Dobbins and Gus Edwards departing in free company, 296 carries are up for grabs between Hampton and free agent signee Najee Harris. The Chargers gave Harris solely a one-year deal after which drafted Hampton with their first decide, so it appears as if Hampton will get the primary crack at incomes the lion’s share of these carries.
The Chargers symbolize a giant alternative for a rusher to go nuclear, too. Solely 27.2% of their carries final season went for extra speeding yards than anticipated, the fourth-worst charge in soccer, per NFL Subsequent Gen Stats. The Chargers needed to transfer away from the run because the season went on. In Weeks 1-4, that they had the fourth-highest run charge over expectation. However in Weeks 14-17, that they had the fourth-highest cross charge over expectation. With a again they belief to constantly create yardage, the Chargers are prone to return to their run-heavy method — and that again, in response to their first-round funding, is Hampton.
1:05
Chargers GM to McAfee: Omarion Hampton was a participant we could not cross on
Chargers basic supervisor Joe Hortiz talks with Pat McAfee in regards to the determination to draft Omarion Hampton within the first spherical.
Two extra operating backs have been taken with early alternatives: Quinshon Judkins by the Browns at No. 36, and TreVeyon Henderson by the Patriots at No. 38. Judkins has a a lot simpler path to increased quantity (beating out incumbent Jerome Ford) than Henderson (who should supplant Rhamondre Stevenson). However Stevenson had unhealthy fumbles final season and is confronted with a brand new teaching employees this yr, so Henderson may sneakily rise to the 1A spot in that rotation sooner than anticipated. Nonetheless, the Browns’ offensive line far surpasses New England’s, so we’ll preserve them stacked with Judkins getting the sting.
1. Cam Ward, Titans
2. Ashton Jeanty, Raiders
3. Omarion Hampton, Chargers
4. Tetairoa McMillan, Panthers
5. Tyler Shough, Saints
6. Travis Hunter, Jaguars
7. Matthew Golden, Packers
8. Emeka Egbuka, Buccaneers
9. Quinshon Judkins, Browns
10. TreVeyon Henderson, Patriots
11. Jaxson Dart, Giants
Regardless of Colston Loveland (Bears) and Tyler Warren (Colts) being top-14 picks, I am unable to put them wherever close to the highest of those rankings. Why? Bowers simply produced what is really one of the best receiving season by a rookie tight finish within the historical past of the sport and garnered precisely one first-place vote. Even when this yr’s quarterback class is way worse, it is nearly inconceivable that both Loveland or Warren may have a greater season than Bowers simply did, so the passion to vote for them over a productive receiver or operating again will not be there. Equally, an offensive lineman has by no means gained the award, and I do not count on that to alter any time quickly.
There are different fascinating dart throws, nonetheless. Broncos operating again RJ Harvey enters an unimaginable offensive nucleus with a ton of carries accessible. He was taken with the sixtieth decide, however of the seven gamers chosen exterior of the primary spherical to win this award previously 25 years, 5 have been operating backs. One was Alvin Kamara, a Day 2 again chosen by Sean Payton in 2017. Kamara cut up touches with Mark Ingram in New Orleans however was so productive as each a runner and cross catcher that he snagged the award in a nasty quarterback yr.
One other identify for consideration: Steelers RB Kaleb Johnson (No. 83 general) joins an offense with 263 vacated carries after Harris’ departure to Los Angeles. Johnson is a superb scheme match with Arthur Smith’s large zone offense (just like what the rookie had at Iowa), and the Steelers will doubtless have to depend on the operating sport given their present emptiness at quarterback. Pittsburgh clearly needs to maintain Jaylen Warren in a timeshare position, so I am not apprehensive about him elbowing Johnson out of the rotation.
Final however not least, listed here are some late-Day 2 and Day 3 passers to look at. It’s not unattainable that Dillon Gabriel (Browns), Shedeur Sanders (Browns) or Will Howard (Steelers) wins the beginning job of their woeful quarterback competitions. Ought to they maintain these jobs your complete season, they’re going to presumably have adequate statistical output to qualify for this award. It is a lengthy shot — you are making an attempt to hit precisely 2016 Dak Prescott, the one non-first-round quarterback to ever win OROY — nevertheless it’s not unattainable.
This is my last record:
1:16
Matt Bowen’s rookie fantasy contributors
Matt Bowen particulars why he believes Jayden Higgins, TreVeyon Henderson and Kaleb Johnson can all be fantasy contributors of their rookie season.
Defensive Rookie of the 12 months
Defensive Rookie of the 12 months is, sadly, a bit bit extra boring to foretell. Since 2000, 22 of the 25 winners have been first-round picks — and all three who weren’t first-rounders have been linebackers taken earlier than decide No. 40 (Shaquille Leonard in 2018, DeMeco Ryans in 2006 and Kendrell Bell in 2001).
And of the 22 first-rounders who’ve gained the award since 2000, Jared Verse — final season’s winner — was the newest drafted at No. 19. Save for Verse and Marcus Peters (2015), all of these Defensive Rookies of the 12 months went within the first half of the primary spherical. We are able to say with some extent of confidence that the league is sweet at drafting impactful defenders early, however we will additionally say with the identical confidence that DROY is a “identify recognition” award.
Seven defenders have been taken within the first 16 picks this yr if you happen to embody Hunter. Three corners have gained the award previously 10 years (Peters, Marshon Lattimore in 2017 and Sauce Gardner in 2022), and interception manufacturing is a big cause. Peters had eight picks in 2015; Lattimore had 5 in 2017. Hunter’s worth as a nook will come from his skill to play the ball actually like a receiver, however the problem is obvious: We do not but know what number of snaps Hunter will get on both aspect of the ball. I am nonetheless prepared to rank Hunter for DROY however at a reduction proportional to his anticipated snap depend.
As such, Giants edge rusher Abdul Carter may be our next-best candidate. He is the favourite at ESPN BET (+250). However he is also prone to have a diminished snap depend relative to our expectations for a top-five decide, as he is becoming a member of a group with established starters in Brian Burns and Kayvon Thibodeaux. Aidan Hutchinson, the 2022 second decide, took 84% of the defensive snaps for the Lions in 12 months 1; Travon Walker, the primary decide that yr, performed 67% for the Jaguars. It is unlikely that Carter will hit these numbers. The 55% of the snaps that 2023 third decide Will Anderson Jr. acquired for the Texans in his rookie season looks as if a extra affordable vary — and Anderson gained the award that yr. My issues about Carter’s snap depend are removed from disqualifying however an impediment value highlighting.
There’s one other fear at play for Browns DT Mason Graham, Dolphins DT Kenneth Grant and Cardinals DT Walter Nolen, and it is positional historical past. A defensive sort out has not gained Defensive Rookie of the 12 months since Aaron Donald in 2014. Donald did it with 9 sacks, and Ndamukong Suh did it in 2010 with 10 sacks. Since Donald, just one different defensive sort out has gotten 9 or extra sacks of their rookie season — Kobie Turner for the Rams in 2023 (9). However once more, it is a identify recognition award. Turner did not simply lose to Anderson, who had seven sacks, however he additionally had fewer votes than fellow defensive sort out Jalen Carter, who had six sacks however was drafted 80 spots earlier by the Eagles.
Graham, Grant and Nolen will all have the identify recognition, however will any produce the nine-plus sacks apparently wanted to register for this award? It is laborious for defensive tackles to build up counting stat manufacturing. Think about that analytics author Seth Walder’s projections have Graham for 7.8 sacks and Nolen for six.7 throughout the first three seasons of their respective careers. Graham by no means had greater than 3.5 sacks in a season in faculty, however I like the truth that he has little or no competitors for snaps in Cleveland and will get to hurry alongside Myles Garrett.
That leaves us with the Georgia alums. Mykel Williams joined the 49ers at decide No. 11, and Jalon Walker was taken by the Falcons 4 picks later. These are my two favourite gamers for Defensive Rookie of the 12 months. They play the splashiest place; edge rushers have gained the award in 5 of the previous six years. They’ve little or no competitors for snaps. Williams must fend off solely Yetur Gross-Matos and Drake Jackson to get alternatives reverse Nick Bosa, whereas Walker may be the highest edge rusher on an Atlanta protection that includes Leonard Floyd and Arnold Ebiketie (plus fellow rookie James Pearce Jr.).
Neither Williams nor Walker was tremendous productive in faculty, however each have landed in defenses that may maximize their ability units. Williams will play beneath legendary defensive position coach Kris Kocurek, who will free him as much as play sooner off the road than he ever did at Georgia. Walker will play beneath coach Raheem Morris, who excelled at that includes a speeding linebacker in Kaden Elliss final season. Williams’ play model and position lends itself to a bit extra pass-rush manufacturing than Walker’s outlook, as we should always count on Walker to spend a while dropping into protection. As such, I give Williams the sting.
OK, here is our base for DROY rankings:
1. Mykel Williams, 49ers
2. Jalon Walker, Falcons
3. Abdul Carter, Giants
4. Travis Hunter, Jaguars
5. Mason Graham, Browns
6. Walter Nolen, Cardinals
7. Kenneth Grant, Dolphins
2:25
Analyzing the Cardinals’ collection of Ole Miss’ Nolen
ESPN NFL draft analysts recap the Cardinals’ collection of Walter Nolen and have a look again at a few of his finest performs and achievements as a Insurgent.
If we increase our scope to incorporate your complete first spherical, we add eight extra defenders to think about. A number of are straightforward to right away downgrade. Ravens security Malaki Starks performs a place that has by no means gained the award. Lions DT Tyleik Williams is a run stuffer buried in a dense depth chart. Steelers sort out Derrick Harmon has a bit extra pass-rush juice and a bit extra alternative for snaps, nevertheless it’s laborious to see a excessive sack ceiling.
Broncos cornerback Jahdae Barron is fascinating, although. If he begins reverse Pat Surtain II, he may see a excessive quantity of cross makes an attempt as opposing quarterbacks keep away from the reigning Defensive Participant of the 12 months. However that is provided that Barron performs a majority of snaps, and he has incumbents Riley Moss and Ja’Quan McMillian to beat. It seems that Barron will initially struggle for that beginning slot job with McMillan, and we have by no means had a slot nook win DROY.
Equally, Eagles linebacker Jihaad Campbell can play a wide range of roles on his protection, however he has a depth chart to slog via. If Campbell is an edge rusher within the professionals, he’ll rotate in for snaps behind Nolan Smith Jr. and Jalyx Hunt; if he is an off-ball linebacker, he’ll do the identical behind Zack Baun and Nakobe Dean. I am unable to outline his position with any confidence, so I am unable to rank him with any confidence, both.
The remaining candidates within the again half of the primary spherical are Bengals edge rusher Shemar Stewart, Falcons edge rusher Pearce and Payments nook Maxwell Hairston. All three are nice choices. Stewart ought to get a ton of the snaps reverse Trey Hendrickson, and if Hendrickson performs for the Bengals in 2025, his gravity may create loads of sack alternatives for Stewart on the opposite aspect. Equally, Hairston will see targets taking part in reverse Christian Benford, and he has the ball abilities and explosive play skill to create not simply interceptions but in addition landing returns.
Pearce is the one with whom I wrestle most. The excellent news: There are many snaps to win on the sting, he is a sack artist by commerce, and the Falcons traded a future first-rounder to get him, indicating they consider in his fast affect. The unhealthy information: I assumed he was dramatically overdrafted and count on his NFL transition to be bumpy. Although he was drafted within the first spherical, the Falcons chosen Walker earlier than Pearce. Pearce may get higher pass-rush alternatives and extra sacks than Walker, as once more, that is his ability set (whereas Walker is effective for his versatility).
Pearce is a tricky nut to crack. I am inclined to fall again on my predraft analysis of him and preserve him someplace within the second tier of candidates.
1. Mykel Williams, 49ers
2. Jalon Walker, Falcons
3. Abdul Carter, Giants
4. Shemar Stewart, Bengals
5. Maxwell Hairston, Payments
6. Travis Hunter, Jaguars
7. Mason Graham, Browns
8. James Pearce Jr., Falcons
9. Walter Nolen, Cardinals
10. Kenneth Grant, Dolphins
11. Jihaad Campbell, Eagles
12. Jahdae Barron, Broncos
13. Derrick Harmon, Steelers
14. Tyleik Williams, Lions
15. Malaki Starks, Ravens
Are there any remaining, intriguing sleepers? I am glad you requested! Browns linebacker Carson Schwesinger has precisely the profile we search for in a non-first-round candidate to win Defensive Rookie of the 12 months. He is an off-ball linebacker chosen on the prime of Spherical 2 (No. 33). He’s a tackling machine, with 115 final season. He can create affect performs towards the cross (three cross breakups and two interceptions). And he joins a Jim Schwartz-coached protection that wishes linebackers to play quick and aggressive — what Schwesinger does finest.
The first query is the snap depend. Veteran Jordan Hicks is anticipated to fill one of many beginning roles, and the other spot belongs to Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah. However Owusu-Koramoah suffered a severe neck harm in Week 8 of final season, and his standing for your complete 2025 marketing campaign is up within the air. By taking Schwesinger this early, the Browns appear to be signaling that they don’t count on Owusu-Koramoah to be accessible.
If Schwesinger wins the beginning job alongside Hicks, he’ll abruptly change into a robust candidate for the type of high-volume season that provides second-round linebackers a path to this award.
For any Cowboys or Ravens fan in search of Donovan Ezeiruaku (No. 44 general) or Mike Inexperienced (No. 59), respectively, I am sorry, however that is one thing we simply by no means see with this award. I do know they have been the highest sack getters within the FBS final season, however the latest-drafted DROY was in 1986, when John Offerdahl gained it from the 52nd decide. Since then, no participant exterior the highest 40 has pulled it off.
So here is my last record for DROY, with our sleeper cracking the highest six:
